Billy Eichner (Bobby Leiber), Luke MacFarlane (Aaron Shepard), Guy Branum (Henry), Miss Lawrence (Wanda), Ts Madison (Angela), Dot-Marie Jones (Cherry), Jim Rash (Robert), Eve Lindley (Tamara), Monica Raymund (Tina), Jai Rodriguez (Jason), Guillermo Diaz (Edgar), Amanda Bearse (Anne), Debra Messing (sie selbst), Kristin Chenoweth (sie selbst), Peter Y. Kim (Peter), Justin Covington (Paul), Symone (Marty), Ryan Faucett (Josh Evans), Becca Blackwell (Lucas), D'Lo (Tom), Bowen Yang (Lawrence Grape), Harvey Fierstein (Lewis), Brock Ciarlelli (Steve), Dahlia Rodriguez (Hannah), Derrick Delgado (Brian), George Dvorsky (Bruce), Jamyl Dobson (Joel), Ben Stiller (er selbst (uncredited)), Seth Meyers (Harvey Milk (uncredited)), Kenan Thompson (James Baldwin), Amy Schumer (Eleanor Roosevelt), Jillian Gottlieb (Samantha), Everett Quinton (Melvin Funk)